Who are the best people to recommend books for young readers? Young readers, without a doubt! After all, we write the books for them so why would we care so much what adults think? (OK, we do care, a lot, but we should care more what the intended readers think.)
How do we find out what they really think? Ask them! So I did! Specifically, I asked the S1 pupils of “my” school, Larbert High School in Falkirk, where I’m the Patron Saint of Reading. These pupils are 12 years old and I love the variety of their views. I asked them (via their librarian and Head of English, Mr Doherty – seen dressed as Where’s Wally during their annual book week) to think about what book they would recommend, from the heart; not to write a formal review but just to say why they liked it. And LOOK how many of them answered!
Here they all are. Please give them lots of support, and the teachers who gathered the responses. Do comment below if you can spare a moment. Thank you!
Chloe Jarvie recommends Lola Rose by Jacqueline Wilson. She loved this book because: “Something interesting happens every sentence; you have to stretch your imagination to pretend you are in the book. My blurb: it’s a mum, dad, brother and big sister, the dad can be loving, caring but with one twist he can become violent and slap the mother. One day he gets so angry he slaps the sister; they have to get away with no money.”
Jacqueline Wilson gets some other nominations, too. Ellie Mclaren loves Candyfloss “because it’s about a friend who is moving and it’s exciting because is the two friends going to stay together or will they split apart!” And Lauren Meiehofer recommends Jacky Daydreams. Lauren says “it is really interesting because it is about a young girl who doesn’t get looked after by her family and her dream is for her mum to get better and on Christmas her mum wakes up all better.”
Skye Adam recommends The Chronicles of Vladimir Todd by Heather Brewer. “I enjoyed this book mainly because it’s my kind of book because the main character is into the same music and basically has the same thoughts as me. Vladimir Todd is a half vampire because his mum was human and his dad was a vampire but sadly his parents died in a house fire and then he has to live with his mum’s best friend who is a doctor so she can give him leftover blood. One of my favourite bits in the book is when Vladimir meets these new gothic teenagers and they ask if he wants to join the group and he’s already an outcast because he’s different, so he goes to a gothic nightclub with them. But my favourite bit is when she makes a gothic girl into his vampire slave.”
Sam likes The Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. “I loved this book because it isn’t real it’s imagining and mystical and magical. I also like the characters.”
Amy Garai loves OMG is this actually my life by Rae Earl. She said, “I loved this book because it was really good and I just don’t really know why it was just really good. And I liked the characters and the storyline. It was so sad when I finished it.”
Megan O’Neill loved The Sausage Lion by Michael Morpurgo “because the dad blames the dog for rumbeling in the bins. Only thing is it’s not the dog it’s the lion. The lion was looking for meat to eat. This story is so exciting!” Hooray for exciting stories!
Ndu Hekrem loved Half Moon Ranch by Jenny Oldfield “because it uses good English and you get lost in the book. It has an extremely good start and finish. It was a very scary, funny book and enjoyable to read. The book starts of scary and becomes funny.” And it has horses, of course!
Barrie Mcallister recommends Diary of a Wimpy Kid by Jeff kinney. Barrie said, “I loved this book because it is modern, funny, interesting story because he writes it like a letter and just keeps you very entertained. I loved this book and you should read it.” Maybe I will! Cameron D also chose it “because it came in a series and they are all funny. It’s about a guy called Greg who is a wimp and he writes a diary about his wimpy summer. The movie is really good too.”
The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins had two eager fans: Brionny J, who said, “I love this book because I don’t want to put it down and it will keep you reading it. It is as good as the movie and it describes things in so much detail! It is the best book I have ever read, it is great! The book is sort of a cliff-hanger and adventure. You have to read them all before you can say its good! And Frazer liked it “because the chapters are amazing and the connection between the characters is unbreakable. It is a five star book.”
Bianca Wright loved the second in the Hunger Games series, Catching Fire, “because it is filled with action and adventure. It is the second in the series and the best in my opinion. I think that the plot is amazing and it builds up to the third book but not in a too revealing way.”
Jordan liked I Funny by James Patterson, “because the characters have really strong personalities. This disabled boy enters the world funniest hiding competition.” Logan Whelan likes another book by James Patterson: I’m in middle school get me out of here. “I like this book because it was really interesting,” he says.
James and the Giant Peach by Roald Dahl had two recommendations. Jamie Forrester said, “I loved book because it’s a brilliant kids book and a funny classical kids book. James moves from his house to his ugly mean auntie’s house. While he is there he plants a peach tree which turns into a giant peach and there is loads of insects in it and James travels in the peach.”. “I loved book because it’s a brilliant kids book and a funny classical kids book. James moves from his house to his ugly mean auntie’s house. While he is there he plants a peach tree which turns into a giant peach and there is loads of insects in it and James travels in the peach.” And Jack Donaldson said, “I really enjoy the characters. It’s an enjoyable book and it’s funny.”
Roald Dahl has some fans, for sure. Rihanna likes Fantastic Mr. Fox “because it is funny to read because Mr Tod is annoying the farmers and stealing all the chickens and eating them with his family and kids.” Sophie Dow recommends Matilda. She says, “I like this book because it is really interesting book about a young girl who has magical powers with her eyes and she gets adopted by her lovely school teacher Miss Honey. I really enjoyed it.”
Rebakah Fleming loved Black Butter by Yana Toboso “because it has so many genres all mashed into one and millions of cliff hangers.” I like the sound of that!
Lucy Bell recommends Torn by David Massey “because I really liked it because it was exciting and different from anything I have read before. I didn’t think I would like it when I first read the blurb to see that it was about the army, which I didn’t think was my kind of thing, but as I read the book it was really exciting seeing what a soldier’s day to day life is like. I would recommend this to anyone over the age of 12.”
Scott Jackson recommends Skull Duggery by Derek Landy to everyone, “because it is fun and it has magic to sadness.” I love the idea of magic and sadness.
Nicky Hogarth loved The Recruit by Robert Muchamore. “It’s a very good book and I really enjoyed it.I didn’t want to put it down, it was funny at times and from then on I read the full series of books that it was in, called CHERUB.
Claire Dickie recommends Thief by Malorie Blackman. She said, “This book was amazing. There were so many twists and turns. It stretches your imagination to the edge. It’s a funfilled-heart-warming story. Families must save each other and can Lydia change her future? A well-written page-turner. It’s a modern classic!” Sounds brilliant, Claire!
Caitlin Ray recommends Horrid Henry by Francesca Simon. She says, “It has lots of different stories in the one book, it’s good for 8-13 year olds or if you’re an adult that doesn’t want to grow up! It’s full of pranks and gross kiddy things, if you like reading really boring things like maths textbooks please do not read this book!” I once reviewed Horrid Henry for the Guardian – I think it’s great.
Abby Dickson loved City of Bones by Cassandra Clare. “I loved this book because it captivated me and I couldn’t put it down. The book introduced me to the world of vampires, werewolves, warlocks and more. I loved it because there are 6 books in the series and I was so intrigued that I wanted to buy the whole series.” That will keep you busy!
Raymond Maxwell recommends Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by J.K Rowling. “I loved this book because it is a different setting with no Quidditch but there is a Quidditch world cup. The best bit was when Lord Voldemort came back in the graveyard.” JK Rowling gets two more recommendations. Cliodhna Reid liked Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. “I liked this book because it goes into a lot of detail about characters, scenes and lots more. When you read the book it is better than it sounds on the blurb. I would recommend this book.” And Jack M went for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. “I liked this book because it was exciting, it was full of action and adventure and an epic final duel between Harry and Voldemort.”
Carrie Hughes recommends a book I keep meaning to read, The Fault In Our Stars by John Green. She said, “I loved this book because I feel like I can relate to it and the characters in it. John Green sucks you in with its alternative romance novel.”
Hollie Charleston loved The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephan Chbosky “because it was exciting and had a good twisted ending. It was also very funny and heart touching.” I’ve heard about this book, but hadn’t got round to it but Hollie has made me want to read it.
Jordyn Smith loved two books: Mates, Dates and Chocolate Cheats by Cathy Hopkins “because it was really funny and it got me into it straight away. The girl in the novel is very funny and everyone should read this book because its great!” And Candy Floss by Jacqueline Wilson. “I loved this book because: its just so good to read! I loved it so much! I didn’t want it to end. As soon as I saw it I knew I wanted to read it. Once you get right into the book you won’t want to stop.” Obviously a keen reader!
Emma McInally loved Alex Rider Storm Breaker by Anthony Horowitz because, “It is action packed and has good sense in it. It’s a really good book and I would recommend it to anyone.”
Blaine Colquhoun recommends The Maze of Bones: 39 clues by Rick Riordan. Blaine said, “I loved this book because it’s filled with mystery and tension. I think it’s clever and brilliant. It’s a page turner and I love it to bits, cannot wait for the rest (also very interesting because all the books are written by different people).” That is interesting!
Benjamin Small loved War Horse by Michael Morpurgo because, “It has good words and punctuation and very good pictures. I would recommend it for you.” I’m going to see War Horse at the theatre in January – can’t wait! Michael Morpurgo gets another recommendation, from Amandalee Davie, who liked Shadow because, “It had some parts which were sad and others were happy. It gave you a really good description of where they were. The book just made you want to read on. An amazing book written by an amazing author.”
Uzair Ahmad loves Shine on Daisy Star by Cathy Cassidy, “because I really liked the characters and how it was written. I couldn’t stop reading when I started because once I read a chapter I had to read the next to see what happens.” Cathy is a friend of mine and I’m thrilled to see her do so well. She’s a very genuine person.
Kenzie Falconer recommends Hell Heroes by Darren Shan. “I loved this book because it was scary and it was interesting as well so you should read it.”
Jack Henderson recommends Ultimate Spiderman learning curve by Brain Michael Bendis. Jack said “It was very hard to put down it also wasn’t too long.” Too good things about a book!
Eilidh Campbell loves Anne Frank’s Diary. “It was amazing as Anne Frank actually wrote it you got to know how she felt. I am really enjoying the book so far.”
Jack Foote loved Holes by Louis Sachar. He said, “I thought it was good and we watched the movie which was fun.” I loved Holes myself – utterly brilliant. It also had an anonymous recommendation: “I like this book because it is a good book and because it’s got lizards in it. He gets let out of camp. He was put in for something he didn’t do and it’s cool.”
Blair Spinks recommends Dinosaurs Cove by Rex Stone. Blair said, “I loved this book because of the storyline and characters. It was fun to read, easy to read and it makes you scared about what is going to happen.”
George Guthrie and Lewis Simpson both recommend Flashpoint by Bernard Ashley. George says, “The detail is really well written showing what the character sees.” And Lewis says, “It was action packed, so exciting, and a brilliant book.”
Jack Dick recommends Mortal Chaos by Matt Dickinson. He says, “If you were reading over the holiday then I would really recommend Mortal Chaos as it is jam packed with different stories with the idea that all things are connected. The stories range from a pilot that ran over a deer to two boys skipping school to hunt a deer to a mountain climber to a horse rider and so on.” Sounds great, Jack.
Liam McCallum likes Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan. “I like this book because it is a good book and the characters are great. This book is a long book. If you like adventures this book is good for you.”
An anonymous reader recommended Room by Emma Donoghue, which, I should say, is a book written for adults. (I believe any reader of any age should read any book they feel ready for, but this is a heart-rending book and all readers of all ages should be aware of that!) “I like this book because it is a really unique storyline about a boy who has lived in one room for all of his life because his mother was kidnapped and raped. The plot twists as they plan to escape. I didn’t want to put it down. It was the best book I’ve read for a long time and it made me really emotional.” I loved it, too.
Thank you to all the pupils for these wonderful and heartfelt recommendations! I hope you get lots more books to enjoy for Christmas. Books are the best presents because they grow our minds and satisfy our souls.
Join me in wishing the whole of LARBERT HIGH SCHOOL and very very happy, relaxing, invigorating, merry, wonderful Christmas holiday!